Compare Listings

Nantucket Restaurant Week: Fisher Favorites


Dining & Food

Photo Credit- Wayne Chinnock for CRU Nantucket Restaurant Week

Before and after the busy summer season, we love to hit up our favorite dining establishments during Nantucket Restaurant Week. We are lucky that this special culinary week happens not once, but twice a year. In 2018, Spring Restaurant Week was held from June 4th-10th and Fall Restaurant Week will take place September 24th-30th.

29 Restaurants from across the island participate, most of which are located in town. However, some are found in other neighborhoods like The Chanticleer and the Summer House in ’Sconset, Galley Beach in Brant Point, Toppers in Wauwinet and The SeaGrille in Mid-Island. Reservations are recommended during Nantucket Restaurant Week. Each restaurant offers a unique menu, so contact them to find out details of their nightly specials!

Without further ado, here are Fisher Real Estate’s favorite delectable dishes during Nantucket Restaurant Week. Click on each person in #TheFisherCrew to learn more about them or invite them to dinner!

Gina O’Callaghan, Sales and Rental Agent

Favorite Restaurant: The Proprietor’s Bar & Table

9 India Street, Nantucket, MA, 1-508-228-7477

Favorite Dish: The Crispy Whole Gulf Shrimp

Gina says, “A substantial portion with more flavor than you would ever think you could find in shrimp.  The perfect crunch and the melt in your mouth texture make for the ideal culinary combo.  Try with their Little Gem Lettuce dish and you have a gorgeous dinner.  Buon Appetito!”

Erin Wilson, Sales and Rental Agent

Favorite Restaurant: CRU Oyster Bar

One Straight Wharf, Nantucket, MA, 1-508-228-9278

Photo Credit: Wayne Chinnock for CRU

Favorite Dish: The lobster roll – lunch or dinner!

Erin says, “Why do I love it? At lunch it is served cold and warmed at dinner and they are both delicious. However, do NOT skip the bun, trust me. Set at the end of the wharf, Cru has a fun, lively ambiance. Your spirits just lift when you walk through the door. The location is tough to beat, looking out at all of the boats just never gets old. And the staff is incredibly friendly and attentive.”

Jen Shalley Allen, Principal Broker

Favorite Restaurant: Ventuno Restaurant

21 Federal Street, Nantucket, MA, 1-508-228-4242

Favorite Dish: So hard to choose just one but if you’re in the mood for pasta then the Strozzapretti is the way to go. This is a homemade pasta with spicy chicken sausage, broccoli rabe and pecorino. Delish!

Jen says, “Ventuno is often my first choice for a Nantucket restaurant as the menu offers so many varied choices and it’s a great value given the quality and portions.  The ambiance is fabulous and offers the opportunity to sit outside on the back patio in great summer weather, or inside in the various dining rooms.  I often vote to sit at the bar with the famous Johnny B — he always remembers your name and if for some reason he doesn’t, he will certainly remember what you’re drinking.”

Brent Tartamella, Sales and Rental Agent

Favorite Restaurant: Seagrille Nantucket

45 Sparks Avenue, Nantucket, MA, 1-508-325-5700

Favorite Dish: Whatever Rich suggests for that evening!

Brent says, “It’s like coming home!  We love the Harveys, their foundation and all that they do for this community.  We always know that Rich will be present at his post at the back bar and can count on great conversation and service.  The relaxed, professional atmosphere and high-quality food is just the SeaGrille standard.  There is never a question of if it will be good and we always look forward to relaxing with a nice glass of wine, great food and fair prices.”

Danno Lynch, Sales and Rental Agent

Favorite Restaurant: Company of the Cauldron

5 India Street, Nantucket, MA, 1-508-228-4016

Favorite Dish: Fried Chicken and Waffles

Danno says, “Unlike any other restaurant on Nantucket, the Company of the Cauldron has a fixed menu every night of the week with two seatings.  Some of the menu stays constant, but it has seasonal variations so you will never have the same meal twice. My favorite night of Nantucket Restaurant Week is on Wednesday when they offer fried chicken and waffles. The dish is served family style and starts with pop overs and salad. They also bring out two side dishes AND dessert. It is great to sit down at a place and feel completely at home and not have to worry about figuring out what to order, they choose the menu for you!”

Cam Gammill, Principal Broker

Favorite Restaurant: Dune Restaurant

20 Broad Street, Nantucket, MA, 1-508-228-5550

Favorite Dishes: Soy Glazed Pork Belly and Seared Yellowfin Tuna

Cam says, “Dune is one of our favorite restaurants to eat at in the winter, the atmosphere is awesome!!! I love their pork belly appetizer and yellowfin tuna. The tuna is served with a roasted cauliflower puree, almond caper relish, pancetta, french lentils, purple cauliflower and red beets. Check it out at Nantucket Restaurant Week for a meal not to miss!” 

Cait Kappler, Rental Manager & Office Coordinator

Favorite Restaurant: Queequeg’s

6 Oak Street, Nantucket, MA, 1-508-325-0992

Favorite Dish: Steak Frites 

Cait says, “Queequeg’s is one of my favorite cozy spots, especially in the off-season. Their menu is the ultimate in comfort food, but with a twist and the chef always has mouth watering specials. I love grabbing seats at the bar with friends and sharing some of their smaller plates or going for one of their “themed” nights. Not to miss: best truffle fries on the island, hands down.”

Marleah Lydon, Office Manager

Favorite Restaurant: The Pearl

12 Federal Street, Nantucket, MA, 1-508-228-9701

Favorite Dishes: 60 Second Steak and the Wok Fried Lobster

Marleah says, “My favorite restaurant for restaurant week is The Pearl. I love the Pearl because it always feels like such a special treat to be there. The atmosphere brings me back to my time working in Boston and that city feel you sometimes crave without having to leave the island. The food is obviously delicious (and amazingly rich), cocktails are on point, and their private dining areas are the perfect place for a special occasion, my personal favorite is the Pink Room!”

Gaelan Truyman, Marketing Manager

Favorite Restaurant: Straight Wharf Restaurant

6 Harbor Square, Nantucket, MA, 1-508-228-4499

Favorite Dishes: Chilled Watermelon Gazpacho and SWR Clam Bake

Gaelan says, “The best meal I ever had on Nantucket was at Straight Wharf during restaurant week. They start off by bringing bread, olive oil and their homemade bluefish pate and end with their signature rosemary shortbread cookies. Choose from one item on their begin, continue and complete menu. SWR continues to be my top choice during restaurant week because they serve the same hearty portions and offer the full menu. Ask the friendly sommelier for wine pairings for an extra special meal!”