Compare Listings

Nantucket Thanksgiving Dinner Take-out + Dine-in Options


Dining & Food

unnamed image

For those who don’t find joy in cooking a dozen Thanksgiving dishes and cleaning for days on end, you’re in luck! There are many other dining options on Nantucket. This is especially helpful if you are coming on-island for the holiday and don’t have a kitchen full of cooking utensils including potato mashers, meat thermometers and roasting pans. Here are some take-away and dine-in options to book in advance of Thursday, November 28th, 2023. Wherever you end up, make sure you start your day by taking a dip in the Harbor at the Fisher Real Estate sponsored Cold Turkey Plunge, read our blog for more!

For take-away prepared meals, you can order just the turkey or everything from the rolls to the pumpkin pies. Some options include:

Bartlett’s Farm (link to menu including Misty Knoll & Koch’s turkeys, and all the fixins’ and dessert)

Nantucket Meat and Fish Market (extensive menu including Misty Knoll turkeys, rib roast, ham, 5 kinds of pie, shrimp cocktail and all the sides)

PPX Events (link to website, menu below)

Bartlett’s Farm (link to menu)

Faregrounds Restaurant (link to website)

Company of the Cauldron (link to menu)

Wicked Island Bakery

Something Natural (link to website)

Lemon Press (link to website)

Hatch’s Package Store (link to website)

Other options include dining at one of our famous local restaurants, so you don’t even have to be bothered with the dishes. Oran Mor and Sister Ship both have sit down dinners. Reach out to The Breeze at The Nantucket Hotel (link to menu) or the Brant Point Grill at The White Elephant to reserve your table for their buffet feasts. Bonus: they both offer live music to brighten the festivities! Another popular option is also the one that the President chooses! Faregrounds Restaurant and Pudley’s Pub is open for a buffet dinner on Thanksgiving from 1-7 (take-out starts a little earlier).

If you know of any other catering companies or restaurants serving Thanksgiving dinner, please let us know!

Happy Thanksgiving, Nantucket!

Bartlett’s Farm Menu

PPX Events & PPX Patisserie Menu

Nantucket Hotel Thanksgiving Feast

Hatch’s Package Store

Something Natural Thanksgiving Order Form

something natural order form thanksgiving

Faregrounds Thanksgiving Dine in and Take Out Menus


Sister Ship