Ranking among the top islands in the world and the U.S., it’s no surprise that Nantucket is home to many incredible properties. While the island’s highest residential sales are far less than those in Palm Beach or Aspen, here is a review of the top sales in 2025 and the highest sales of all time. Three of the 2025 transactions also appear in the top 10 list of the island record residential sales.
2025:
#1) 3 Sherburne Way: $37.75 million (private sale)
#2) 8 Sachem Way: $31 million (private sale)
#3) 86 Pomoco Road: $26.5 million
#4) 14 Lincoln Avenue: $21 million (Fisher RE)
#5) 30 Eel Point Road: $19 million
#6) 1 Ocean Avenue: $18 million (Fisher RE)
#7) 248 Polpis Road: $16.85 million (Fisher RE)
#8) 113 Eel Point Road: $16.5 million
#9) 14 Basset Road: $16.34 million
#10) 15 Pleasant Street: $15.45 million
All Time:
#1) $42 Million: 68 & 72 Monomoy Road, Monomoy, Nantucket (Sold on September 29, 2023)
#2) $38.1 Million: 20, 21 & 22 Berkeley Avenue, Monomoy, Nantucket (Sold on June 30, 2023)
#3) $37.75 Million: 3 Sherburne Way, Cliff, Nantucket (Sold on October 8, 2025)
#4) $36 Million: 21 Lincoln Avenue, Cliff, Nantucket (Sold on April 15, 2022)
Link to Sales Info at NantucketCurrent.com
#5) $33 Million: 63 & 63.5 Hulbert Avenue, Brant Point, Nantucket (Sold on October 3, 2022)
#6) $31 Million: 8 Sachem Way,Cliff, Nantucket (Sold on September 30, 2025)
#7) $27.5 Million: 11 & 15 Cathcart Avenue, Monomoy, Nantucket (Sold on December 31, 2010)
#8) $27.1 Million: 9 Kimball Avenue, Cliff, Nantucket (Sold on December 8, 2014)
#9) $26.88 Million: 25 Nonantum Avenue, Surfside, Nantucket (Sold on May 31, 2023):
#10) $26.5 Million: 86 Pocomo Road, Pocomo, Nantucket (Sold on August 10, 2025):