Call Us: (508) 228-4407

Top 5 Nantucket Restaurants

Many say, “if you’re lucky enough to be on Nantucket, you’re lucky enough”, so who would need to seek out the best of the best culinary experiences on the planet?  Someone looking to WOW that special someone, someone like me who has zero interest cooking in the summer, or a group of friends out to experience the island in its entirety. This blog offers up the top 5 restaurants for date night, for groups of friends, and for beach grub hot spots. Reservations are strongly suggested!

The Top 5 Restaurants for a Date Night

brunch in nantucket

The ‘Sconset Café

Get the window seat facing Main St, at sunset.  You will feel transported to another land and experience the old and truly organic feel of Nantucket.  ‘Sconset Cafe is a BYOB restaurant

Galley Beach

Go at sunset and you may have the feeling of not even being on Nantucket. A table on the beach, sand on your toes and your favorite libation in hand, you will think you’re in heaven at Galley Beach.


Arrive by their shuttle which leaves from the docks in front of the White Elephant. Toppers is an elegant setting, an extensive award winning wine list, a relaxing experience that is more than just the food.  A true Nantucket experience not to be missed.

Straight Wharf

Fresh, local ingredients and true summer classics in a romantic setting. Wander down to Straight Wharf, enjoy dinner, then an ice cream and wander the docks.  

American Seasons

Sit under the awning at a candle lit table and vines surrounding you. Then bite into the menu, which will not disappoint.  At American Seasons, you’ll find yourself slowly relaxing and melting away into your chair.  


The Top 5 Restaurants for a Groups of Friends 

Cru Nantucket Restaurant

The Proprietors Bar & Table

Chef Mike Lascola and his wife, Orla have cornered the market on shareable plates. Proprietor’s features dishes created with Nantucket’s seasonal offerings, excellent cocktails, and an atmosphere that welcomes people from all walks of life.  


A delicious rustic Italian experience that will leave you wanting to return time and time again.  As a group on a hot summer night, get a table at the outside back bar then roll your evening into a fun after dinner party at Ventuno


Chef Erin Zircher and her team bring the freshest of the sea to you each and every lunch and evening throughout the summer at Cru.  A shareable seafood tower is the way to go if you are with a Cru… they have appropriately named it the Grand Cru. 


Great food, a great location and a light and always FUN atmosphere.  Set among the docks at the end of Old South Wharf, you may even catch a boat returning with a giant catch while you dine at Slip


At the bar, at a high top, at the private corner table, outside, or at the sushi bar, there is a table for everyone at Lola. And a menu with selection for all!  


The Top 5 Food Truck & Beach Grub Locations 

Surfside Beach Shack and Taco Truck

Two reviews in one!  Salads, chicken sandwiches and ice cream at your traditional beach side food shack… or venture around the corner of the parking lot to the Taco truck – exactly as it sounds and quite yummy. Order ahead of time, stop for a quick lunch or better yet, ride your bike out and burn off that ice cream!

167 Raw

Lobster rolls, tuna burgers, poke and more, oh my!  When you’re looking for a nice lite bite, stop by the 167 Raw food truck located outside of their fish market, and enjoy your meal in their garden.

Nantucket Lobster Trap

Located at Cisco Brewery (who doesn’t know where that is??). They’re a fixture at the brewery on the weekends, offering great fried foods and specials… they also offer a Little Red Truck for catering events. 

Millie’s Cart

Visit the Millie’s food cart at the Brewery or rent the cart for a private event!  Offering baha cuisine favorites such as chicken, steak and fish tacos, quesadillas and Mexican street corn. 

Nantucket Poke

Traditional Hawaiian poke bowls – yum!  They donate a portion of their sales to local organizations that focus on land and ocean conservation.  Visit their site for the truck locator.


Gina O’Callaghan

A Sturbridge, Massachusetts native, Gina found herself washed ashore on Nantucket in 2000 when she arrived to work as a project manager for a well-regarded high-end general contractor. Having enjoyed the opportunity to interact with homeowners and help shepherd their visions to life, it was a natural fit when she entered the Nantucket real estate scene in 2014. In less than 4 years, Gina has successfully closed on over $54 million in sales on the island. She also brings 7 years of off-island sales in both the commercial and residential markets. Gina aims to provide each and every one of her clients with a positive, professional and stress-free experience when looking to buy, sell or rent.
When not working, you’ll find Gina boating and fishing with her husband and their two daughters, Roisin and Scarlett, out walking the dog or enjoying one of our many pristine beaches.

Key Accomplishments:
• Average Nantucket Sale Price: $3,125,000.
• Total Closed transaction sides: 80
• $54,819,000 Total Sales
• Sales ranging up to $10,800,000
• Licensed Real Estate agent and Broker since 2004
• Average listing sell price to average last asking price: Gina (97%) vs. the average Nantucket agent (93%)
• Gina's Average Listing Days on Market: 111 days compared to the average Nantucket agent: 195 days.

"Thank you so much for helping us so graciously through the process of purchasing our first Nantucket home! You have done a superb job guiding us patiently thru the Nantucket maze and for that, we owe you."
“You were so accommodating, even keeled and sweet. We have been involved in many real estate transactions and this experience was the very best we have had to date, thank you”.
“I want very much to take a heartfelt moment to thank you. Thank you for your determination and guidance in what has been a dream of ours since we first met working as Lifeguards years ago. Just a message sending good vibes, appreciation, and mad respect!!!”
"We found someone we can trust and guide us in Gina"
“Gina and the Fisher team were amazing to work with. We shifted our focus several times (buying a house to buying land back to a house), and through every ‘shift’ the only focus was to guide and educate us to make the best decision for my family. Attention to detail and the response...simply amazing. I do not write reviews, but Gina and the team deserve the recognition.”