Compare Listings

Erin’s “Fresh Catch” of Rental Homes on Nantucket


Vacation Rentals

unnamed image

Is your Nantucket vacation on the top of your mind this February? Sales & Rental Agent Erin Wilson has assembled her five-star list of rentals that must be calling your name! From Town to Cisco (one of Erin’s favorite neighborhoods) and priced from $4K to $19K, take a peek at these five options with open availability this summer and one that is even pet-friendly!

See where Erin thinks you should rent…

62A Orange Street, Nantucket

Check full availability of 62A Orange Street

This three-bedroom beauty underwent a complete renovation (and transformation!) in 2019.  The historic home feels brand new with an open layout on the first floor with a top of the line kitchen. At 62A Orange St, you are close to both Main Street and the Harbor, as this house is a very convenient in-town location. There are three bedrooms: King, King and a third floor perfect for kids with four beds. The home will be newly decorated and furnished for Summer 2020!


2 Cato Lane, Nantucket

Check full availability of 2 Cato Lane

This is a great location, right on the edge of town so you have easy access to so many areas including one of my favorites, Cisco! The home was built just two years ago, has three en-suite bedrooms and a great open layout on the first floor that opens up to the pool area. The pool and patio areas are stunning and serene, surrounded by green space offering privacy too! 


10 East Dover Street

Check full availability of 10 East Dover Street

This charming cottage is located in town, right up the street from the Frances Street Beach. There are three bedrooms, one full bathroom (recently renovated!) and an outdoor shower! There is off street parking and a wonderful patio area in the back to enjoy the nice weather. Main Street is close-by and if you have a craving for a lobster roll, Sayle’s Seafood is just down the street!

1 Davis Lane

Check full availability of 1 Davis Lane

This five-bedroom home is located in Cisco, an area I love to spend time in. When town gets busy, you have access to Bartlett’s Farm, Cisco Brewers and 167 Seafood. This home was recently built, it is nice and spacious. The kitchen and living areas are located on the second floor to take advantage of the views. There is plenty of space for everyone to spread out as there is also a finished basement with another living area. One of my favorite things about this property is the inviting and HUGE lawn! Get your yard games ready, what a perfect vacation spot!

31 Madaket Road


This recently renovated, 3-bedroom home is located just on the edge of town. Originally a farm, the back of the home looks out onto open fields and there is a large patio perfect for alfresco dining. The bike path is directly across the street, this location is very convenient!  For a fee, the home will allow pets based on the request.