Compare Listings

Sarah’s “Fresh Catch” of Rental Homes on Nantucket


Vacation Rentals

Sarah Holmes
unnamed image

It’s officially 2020 and a great time to book your Nantucket vacation rental for this summer! Sales and Rental Agent Sarah Holmes put together five gorgeous Fisher rentals that have been some of our top rentals over the years. Sarah is officially in her second year with Fisher and has gained a deep knowledge of the island’s communities, homes, beaches, activities and events. She would love to share her insight with you as part of the process of renting a vacation home through Fisher Real Estate.

See where Sarah thinks you should rent, either in popular months liek July or August, the shoulder seasons or even Daffodil Festival or Stroll Festival!

1 Hedgebury Lane, Nantucket

Check full availability of 1 Hedgebury Lane

This ideal in-town property is just moments to the top of Main Street. The charming updated home sits on half an acre complete with a three-bedroom main home, three-season porch, private pool and even a pool house with an extra bedroom.

*The interior of this home is currently being redesigned. Summer 2020 renters will enjoy new furniture, linens, TV’s and fresh paint throughout. Email or call to see updated photos.


2 South Water Street, Nantucket

Check full availability of 2 South Water Street

Located in the heart of downtown Nantucket, this two-bedroom second floor apartment offers easy access to world-class dining, boutiques, art galleries, museums, and beaches. This light and bright apartment provides views of both South Water Street and lower Main Street. Enjoy days at the North Shore beaches and nights strolling through Town and on the docks.


3 Old Farm Road

Check full availability of 3 Old Farm Road

Woodland Hill is an exclusive enclave of luxury homes uniquely located just outside the Old Historic District, moments from shops, restaurants, and all that Downtown Nantucket has to offer. Surrounded by 20 acres of dedicated open spaces, this property provides a serene respite from the hustle and bustle of city life. The property has been impeccably designed, furnished and decorated, boasting 6 bedrooms, 6+ bathrooms, with over 6,000 square feet of living space. This home could be your Nantucket oasis!


*Please note, this property is also available for sale.

54 Monomoy Road

Check full availability of 54 Monomoy Road

A beautifully renovated and rebuilt home on the harbor in Monomoy. Designed with a great sense of space and color, this home is a treat for the senses. Mesmerizing views of the harbor from practically every room, modern sensibility and design mixed with a beachy clean palette makes this home very warm and inviting. Extensive beach with fantastic views towards Town and Brant Point Light.

325 Polpis Road


Enjoy tranquility at this 3+ acre property abutting conservation land and walking trails. The home is a pleasant 12-minute drive from the hustle and bustle of Downtown Nantucket and is within minutes of ‘Sconset Village and Quidnet Beach along the Polpis bike path.


Written By

Sarah Holmes

Sarah grew up in New Hampshire and Vermont and summered on Nantucket with family. Upon graduating from the University of New Hampshire...