Compare Listings

Rental

55 Orange St

$25,000

-

$30,000/ week

Inquire Email To A Friend
close

Historic Nantucket Retreat on Lyon & Orange Streets. Step into classic Nantucket charm at this exquisitely restored 1824 home, built by Captain John C. Gardner and thoughtfully updated for today’s relaxed island living. Located on a sunny corner of Lyon Street, this five-bedroom residence formerly owned by an Olympic gold medalist, offers a seamless blend of historic detail and modern comfort — perfect for families or groups seeking an elegant, walk-to-town getaway. Enjoy beautiful natural light, inviting indoor and outdoor living spaces, and a private garden sanctuary with off-street parking for two.

Additional Details

Enter through a gracious foyer that sets the tone with its original woodwork and timeless character. The front parlor offers a cozy place to unwind by the fireplace, while the adjoining second parlor opens to the dining room and modern kitchen — ideal for gathering after a day at the beach. The chef’s kitchen features high-end appliances, a large center island for casual dining, and a built-in bar perfect for entertaining. French doors lead to the private bluestone patio and pergola-shaded dining area surrounded by mature landscaping. A powder room and convenient side entrance complete this level.

The central staircase leads to a bright landing with space for a writing desk or reading nook. A front guest suite includes harbor peeks and an ensuite bath, while the central bedroom offers flexibility for sleeping or lounging. The primary suite anchors the rear of the house, featuring abundant windows, custom built-ins, and a spa-like bath with a soaking tub, glass shower, and dual vanities. A dedicated washer and dryer are tucked discreetly within the suite for guest convenience.

The upper-level features two charming bedrooms off an open landing — an ideal retreat for children, guests, or extended family. This level also includes a shared full bath and a Clearlight infrared sauna. A private stairway leads to the widow’s walk, where panoramic views stretch across town and toward the harbor — the perfect spot for sunrise coffee or sunset cocktails.

The finished lower level offers a welcoming family room with full-size windows, a separate exterior entrance, and an additional ensuite bedroom. There is also a secondary laundry area and a temperature-controlled wine storage nook. The space combines comfort and practicality, offering a great escape for movie nights or quiet downtime after a day exploring Nantucket.

Property Information

  • 10
  • 6
  • Second Floor
  • Second Floor
  • Second Floor
  • Third Floor
  • Third Floor
  • Lower Level
  • 5.5
  • Sat
  • 5
  • $ 30,000
  • 1
  • $ 25,000
  • Yes
  • Yes
  • 1/4 mile
  • In Town
  • Yes
  • 0
  • Central Air
  • C0560311970
  • 029536
  • Off Street
  • 2 parking spots

Amenities

listing property icon Property

  • Outdoor Furniture
  • Patio
  • Yard

listing outdoor icon Outdoors

  • Beach Chairs
  • Beach Towels
  • Gas BBQ

listing household icon Household

  • Stove - Gas
  • Heat - Oil
  • Air Conditioning - Central Air
  • Dryer
  • Iron
  • Ironing Board
  • Washer
  • Blender
  • Coffee Maker
  • Disposal
  • Microwave
  • Mixer
  • Toaster
  • TVs
  • WiFi

Published rates do not include local & state taxes. Current state tax is 5.7% and current local tax is 6%. A community impact fee of 3% may also apply to some rental properties per local regulations. These tax rates are all subject to change and will be finalized at the time occupancy transfers.

We are in the process of confirming 2026 rates with homeowners. Rates are subject to change upon booking. Please contact Fisher to confirm.

Location

Google Map of 55 Orange St

NEIGHBORHOOD

Town

Historically preserved and simply beautiful, downtown Nantucket can be equated to nowhere else in the world. This is the heart of the island, replete with original cobblestone streets, waterfront restaurants and charming grey-shingled shops. Many of the stunning homes abut pocket gardens heavy in hydrangea and climbing roses, like something out of a painting. Come…

wave beach icon
tower town icon

Request More Information

55 Orange St

$25,000

-

$30,000/ week

  • 10 Guests
  • 6 Beds
  • 5.5 Baths