Compare Listings

Rental

11 Milk St

$10,000

-

$15,000/ week

Inquire Email To A Friend
close

Step back in time without sacrificing modern comfort at 11 Milk Street, a beautifully restored 18th-century Quaker-style home in the heart of Nantucket’s historic district. This timeless residence blends period charm with sophisticated updates. Guests enjoy 4 bedrooms, 3 and a half baths, and inviting gathering spaces that balance heritage and ease. From the preserved pine floors and original fireplaces to the sun-filled modern kitchen, every detail evokes the island’s rich past. Outside, a private brick patio and on-site parking make this in-town gem both convenient and serene—perfect for family getaways or couples traveling together.

Additional Details

The first level welcomes you with a warm front parlor framed by antique paneling and a working fireplace—a perfect spot to unwind after a day of exploring. A formal dining room centers around an impressive inglenook hearth, while a cozy den (once the Starbuck family’s birthing room) offers flexible space as an extra bedroom or reading nook, complete with a powder room and Dutch door to the private patio. Toward the rear, the bright and spacious eat-in kitchen features a central island, breakfast bar, and walk-in pantry, ideal for entertaining or casual mornings. A rear staircase provides direct access to the primary suite above, and a mudroom with laundry ensures every comfort for longer stays.

Upstairs, a sunlit landing doubles as a home office or quiet retreat. The front bedroom includes a fireplace and private bath, while the middle bedroom offers another fireplace and a full bath with tub/shower. The primary suite spans the rear of the home with soaring cathedral ceilings, a luxurious ensuite bath with double vanities, soaking tub, and walk-in shower, plus a private stair to the attic. Each room reflects thoughtful craftsmanship and modern amenities within the home’s historic frame—creating a rare and authentic Nantucket experience.

Property Information

  • 5
  • 3
  • Second Floor
  • Second Floor
  • Second Floor
  • 3.5
  • Sat
  • 3
  • $ 15,000
  • 1
  • $ 10,000
  • Yes
  • Yes
  • 1.5 miles
  • In Town
  • Yes
  • Central Air
  • C0551481970
  • 029306
  • Off Street
  • 1 parking spot

Amenities

listing property icon Property

  • Outdoor Furniture
  • Patio
  • Yard

listing outdoor icon Outdoors

  • Beach Chairs
  • Beach Towels
  • Cooler
  • Fire Pit
  • Gas BBQ
  • Outdoor Shower

listing household icon Household

  • Stove - Gas
  • Heat - Gas
  • Air Conditioning - Central Air
  • Dryer
  • Iron
  • Ironing Board
  • Steamer
  • Washer
  • Blender
  • Coffee Maker
  • Dishwasher
  • Food Processor
  • Microwave
  • Mixer
  • Toaster
  • Sonos
  • TVs
  • WiFi

Published rates do not include local & state taxes. Current state tax is 5.7% and current local tax is 6%. A community impact fee of 3% may also apply to some rental properties per local regulations. These tax rates are all subject to change and will be finalized at the time occupancy transfers.

We are in the process of confirming 2026 rates with homeowners. Rates are subject to change upon booking. Please contact Fisher to confirm.

Location

Google Map of 11 Milk St

NEIGHBORHOOD

Town

Historically preserved and simply beautiful, downtown Nantucket can be equated to nowhere else in the world. This is the heart of the island, replete with original cobblestone streets, waterfront restaurants and charming grey-shingled shops. Many of the stunning homes abut pocket gardens heavy in hydrangea and climbing roses, like something out of a painting. Come…

wave beach icon
tower town icon

Request More Information

11 Milk St

$10,000

-

$15,000/ week

  • 5 Guests
  • 3 Beds
  • 3.5 Baths