Thrifting, Consigning & Vintage Shopping on Nantucket

Thrifting on Nantucket is full of charm, surprises, and timeless style. Tucked among the cobblestone streets and hydrangea-filled lanes are shops that offer more than just secondhand goods. They offer stories, craftsmanship, and the pleasure of discovering something unexpected. Whether you’re searching for a vintage basket bag, a perfectly worn-in Nantucket sweatshirt, or a piece of local artwork, these stops are absolutely worth your time. Here are Nantucket’s vintage shops and thrift stores for secondhand finds.

Hospital Thrift Shop

17 India Street

@hospitalthriftshop

An island institution since 1929, the Hospital Thrift Shop is the heart and soul of Nantucket’s secondhand scene. This charming, multi-level shop offers everything from vintage costume jewelry and barely-worn cashmere to classic homewares and island art. Locals and visitors alike return year after year, knowing that proceeds benefit Nantucket Cottage Hospital. The staff is warm, knowledgeable, and happy to help. If you’re hoping to score a designer jacket or a pair of Nantucket reds, get there early. The good stuff goes quickly!

Hours:

Monday, Wednesday & Friday: 10AM – 12:30PM and 1:00PM – 3:30PM

Tuesday & Thursday: 1:00PM – 3:30PM and 5:30PM – 8:00PM

Saturday: 10:00AM – 12:30PM

Closed Sunday

Take-It-or-Leave-It (TIOLI)

188 Madaket Road

Okay, hear us out, this spot is renowned. Take-it or Leave it’s mission is to reduce landfill waste by giving residents access to reusable items and keeping usable goods out of the trash. Set just past the landfill (yes, really), this open-air exchange invites locals to drop off furniture, books, kitchenware, and clothing they no longer need. The joy here is in the randomness; you might walk away with a vintage tennis racquet, a hand-painted tray, or a lamp that needs just a new shade and a little love. There are no prices and no pressure. Bring your creativity, and keep an open mind.

Hours: 

Wednesday to Friday: 9:00AM – 1:30PM

Saturday & Sunday: 9:00AM – 11:30PM

Closed Monday & Tuesday

Rainbow Fleet

167 Orange Street

@therainbowfleet

Rainbow Fleet is a gem tucked mid-island, offering a beautifully curated mix of secondhand and vintage clothing, shoes, and accessories. From timeless denim and silk blouses to bold prints and one-of-a-kind finds, the shop is a joyful blend of personal style and sustainability. Founded by a ninth-generation Nantucketer, Rainbow Fleet was created with one clear mission: to offer fashion that’s accessible, empowering, and for all women, regardless of size, style, or budget. The space itself is bright and welcoming. It’s the kind of place where you can try on something unexpected, feel completely at ease, and maybe walk out with your new favorite piece

Hours: Monday–Saturday: 10:00 AM–5:00PM
Closed Sunday

Space Nantucket

4 Old South Wharf

@spacenantucket

Tucked along the wharf, Space is where high-end vintage meets island elegance. The shop feels more like a gallery than a thrift store, showcasing a mix of hand-selected vintage clothing, stylish home decor, and artwork by local photographers. The aesthetic is clean, coastal, and quietly chic, blending island spirit with timeless style!

Hours: Open daily from 10AM – 4PM 

Closed Wednesday

BON TON

10 Easy Street

This hidden gem can be a bit tricky to find, but it’s just steps from Nautilus. BON TON is a haven for those who appreciate quality craftsmanship and the thrill of a well-made find. The shop offers a beautifully curated selection of designer consignment and timeless vintage; smart tailored jackets, crisp blouses, classic linens and the occasional Chanel or Hermès surprise. The racks are arranged beautifully to allow browsing at a leisurely pace. Warm and welcoming staff know the inventory well and are eager to help. Overall, BON TON is well worth the visit.

Hours: vary

Commonwealth

16 Federal Street

@commonwealthnantucket

Commonwealth is a designer consignment store with a distinctly elevated feel. The space is beautifully designed with well organized, meticulously preserved pieces that lean classic rather than costume. Visitors will be dazzled by beautifully tailored blazers, timeless dresses, fine jewelry, and elegant accessories. Every item feels intentional, with an emphasis on quality fabrics and enduring design. Commonwealth is a standout on the island for those who prefer subtle sophistication over trends. Check out their new shop on Federal Street!

Hours: Open daily, 10:00AM – 9:00PM

Seconds Shop 

32 Sparks Avenue

@secondsshopnantucket

Everything at the Seconds Shop is donated by members of the Nantucket community, which gives the shop a lovely sense of local character. Better still, every purchase supports Fairwinds, Nantucket’s Behavioral Health Center, so your new-to-you silk blouse or coastal landscape painting comes with the added benefit of helping an important community resource.

Hours:
Sunday-Tuesday: 10:00AM – 4:00PM

Thursday-Saturday:10:00AM – 4:00PM

Closed Wednesday

Island Treasures

128 Old South Road

@island.treasures

This compact shop is packed with finds that range from practical to nostalgic. The shelves are stocked full of housewares, clothing, accessories, books, and more. Prices are modest, making it easy to walk out with something useful or fun without spending much at all. It has the feel of an old-school thrift store. Shoppers may walk in looking for one thing and leave with something they didn’t know they needed!

Hours: 

Monday: 10:00AM – 4:00PM

Tuesday-Friday: 10:00AM – 3:30PM

Saturday: 10:30AM – 2:00PM

Closed Sunday

Kelsey Gund

Born and raised in Weston, Massachusetts, Kelsey has spent every summer on Nantucket and considers the island her second home. She’s currently a rising junior at the University of Wisconsin–Madison, where she studies Consumer Behavior and Marketing. When she’s not assisting with Fisher’s marketing, you’ll likely find her running along the bike paths, playing tennis, or trying new foods on the island.