Compare Listings


Town- 23 Broad Street

  • 9 Beds
  • 5.5 + 7 half baths
  • 0.23 acres
  • details iconDetails
Jun 30 2021
Request Information Email To A Friend

23 Broad Street is a commercial building in the old historic district of Nantucket. The lower level of the building was formerly operated as the "Brotherhood of Thieves" restaurant and bar. The cozy iconic gathering place was originally established in 1972 and was reminiscent of an 1840's whaling bar. The Brotherhood was recognized as a well established gathering place for locals and tourists for many years. Nine residential rooms on the third and fourth floor were used as employee housing. There are two parking places and a loading zone.

Town- 23 Broad Street placeholder

Additional Details

The second level or the first floor is the main entrance/lobby, consists of a large bar with street views of Broad Street, two spacious dining rooms, gas fireplace, service station, two restrooms, a commercial kitchen, managers office and a two stop elevator.

The third floor is employee housing that has 3 bedrooms a shared kitchen and two baths. The kitchen has a set of stairs that lead to the ground level.

The fourth floor ]has six bedrooms, two bathrooms and a laundry area.

The lower level, of which most of the space is above grade, consists of the bar/dining area, two gas fireplaces, two restrooms, service station, a commercial prep kitchen with walk-in freezer. Two stop elevator.
Two mechanical rooms and liquor cage.

Property Information

  • -
  • 9
  • 5.5
  • 7
  • 0.23 acres
  • 1850
  • 2004
  • CDT
  • -
  • Town
  • Town
  • None, Twn
  • Stone
  • Wood, cement, carpet, tile


listing property icon Property

  • Alarm
  • Central A/C
  • Insulation

listing outdoor icon Outdoors

  • Garden
  • Patio
  • Utility Easements. Patio
  • Off-Street

listing household icon Household

  • Cable
  • OFHW
  • Yes, Commercial
  • Yes


Google Map of 23 Broad Street, Nantucket, MA, USA



Historically preserved and simply beautiful, downtown Nantucket can be equated to nowhere else in the world. This is the heart of the island, replete with original cobblestone streets, waterfront restaurants and charming grey-shingled shops. Many of the stunning homes abut…

wave beach icon
tower town icon

Request More Information

Town- 23 Broad Street


  • 9 Beds
  • 5.5 + 7 half baths
  • 0.23 acres

Listing History

Town- 23 Broad Street

Property Type: Commercial
Town- 23 Broad Street Image