Compare Listings

Tax-Free Rentals


Vacation Rentals

unnamed image

What could be better than a week-long vacation on Nantucket? We may have found the answer – a TAX-FREE Nantucket vacation rental.

Short-term rentals are subject to tax. The state room excise and local short-term rental taxes (5.7% and 6%, respectively) total 11.7%. However, there are two different ways where you wouldn’t pay taxes for your Nantucket vacation rental.

⚪ The first tax-free rental option is to book a lease that lasts 32 days or longer.

⚪ A secondary tax-free rental option is when a homeowner chooses to rent their property for 14 days or less in a calendar year.

Browse these rentals if you’re interested in staying for the long haul, tax-free! 

***We are in the process of confirming 2023 rates with homeowners, please note rates and taxes are subject to change upon booking. Please contact Fisher to confirm.

18 Parson Lane – Lara’s Pick


$37,500/ peak week rate

This stunning state-of-the-art property offers a five-bedroom house with multiple living spaces over three floors, including a gym, game room, and entertainment room, all fully integrated with an interior/exterior Sonos sound system.

nantucket vacation rental

97 West Chester Street – Quinn’s Pick


$40,000 week/ peak week rate

As soon as you drive through the gates of 97 West Chester Street onto the stone walled entrance court, you immediately notice that no detail has been overlooked in this masterfully designed and flawlessly executed compound.

nantucket vacation rental

85 Somerset Road – Danno’s Pick

June 16-July 22


$12,000/ peak week rate

Situated in the highly desired Miacomet area, this home is moments from Miacomet Golf Course, Bartlett’s Farm and Cisco Brewery.

nantucket vacation rental

2 Ash Lane – Danno’s Pick

July availability


$15,000/ peak week rate

Moments from the heart of downtown sits this immaculately maintained Greek Revival home. Featuring a post and beam construction, this home offers all modern appliances and amenities you could ask for.

nantucket vacation rental

12 Towaddy Lane – Liza’s Pick

6-weeks from the end of June through the first week of August


$4,500/ peak week rate

Located in a quiet ‘Sconset cul de sac, sits this charming three-bedroom home. Offering plenty of outdoor space to enjoy our warm Nantucket evenings and just moments to ‘Sconset Village.

107 main st nantucket vacation rental

107 Main Street – Liza’s Pick

Available all summer except the week of July 22-29


$16,000/ peak week rate

Perched at the top of Main Street across from the monument, you’ll find 107 Main Street. This home has been recently updated while preserving the history of the property.

nantucket vacation rental

21 West York Lane – Liza’s Pick

Available for the first two weeks of August


$5,500/ peak week rate

This two-bedroom cottage is tucked off a side street in the Historic District and close to the mid-island area. There is wonderful outdoor space with a gas grill, outdoor dining area and sun loungers as well as off street parking for one car.


nantucket vacation rental

15 Meeting House Lane – Liza’s Pick

Available the first two weeks of August


$9,500/ peak week rate

Situated at the end of a quiet lane, 15 Meetinghouse Lane has four-bedrooms and two baths and plenty of outdoor living space. This property is only moments to ‘Sconset Village which offers restaurants, a market, liquor store, post office and a café.


nantucket vacation rental

9 Lily Street – Joelle’s Pick


$12,500/ peak week rate

Located in the heart of downtown Nantucket this beautiful historic home was lovingly renovated in 2022. Boasting 4 bedrooms, 3 full and 1 half bath this property accommodates a family that wants to enjoy all of downtown and the island has to offer.


nantucket vacation rental

8 Pinkham Circle – Brent’s Pick


$13,900/ peak week rate

This spacious home is perfect for a Nantucket getaway and just outside the Old Historic District. This newly built, five-bedroom home can comfortably sleep up to 11 guests and offers an open floor plan, large front porch and a back porch that overlooks the beautiful backyard.

nantucket vacation rental

9 Grey Lady Lane – Brent’s Pick


$21,595/ peak week rate

This large, newly constructed home has three levels of living space and is tastefully designed by award winning architect Workshop/APD. The six-bedroom home is located on one of Nantucket’s newest streets, Grey Lady Lane, its location offers convenient access to the bike path and South Shore Beaches.

3 Raceway Drive – Liza’s Pick


$35,000/ peak week rate

West on ACK is a new, custom home in the Miacomet and Hummock Pond Road area, only moments away from Cisco Brewery, Bartlett Farm, Miacomet Golf Course, 167 Raw and south shore beaches.

28 Long Pond Drive – Jen’s Pick


$20,000/ peak week rate

Located in Nantucket’s treasured west end, this property is perched along Long Pond and affords stunning vistas across the water to hundreds of acres of conservation land. The four-bedroom, three-bathroom main house was recently completely renovated and offers two living areas, freshly appointed bedrooms, and an expansive back porch on both levels to enjoy the best of summer living.

91 Goldfinch Drive – Gina’s Pick


$7,500/ peak week rate

This beautiful property is located close to bike paths, NRTA Wave routes and was recently renovated with desirable amenities. The home sleeps 10 on three floors. Enjoy communal amenities including a heated saltwater pool, children’s pool, tennis courts, pickleball court and a new playground.

63A Lovers Lane- Gina’s Pick


$25,000/ peak week rate

This modernized Surfside property has been restyled and designed with an open feel, clean lines and crisp details. With 5 bedrooms, a finished basement and playroom, this home accommodates up to 14 people.