Compare Listings

2022 Fisher Travel Guide: Nantucket Restaurant Guide


Dining & Food

Fisher Real Estate
nantucket dinner

Whether you want to grab a sandwich to-go on your way to the beach or enjoy a fine glass of wine over an expertly crafted meal, consult the list below for all of our Island’s best dining options with our Nantucket Restaurant Guide.

nantucket food


Faregrounds | 508.228.4095 | Local sports pub with American comfort food and patio seating.

The Charlie Noble | 508.825.5260 | Family-friendly pub with New England seafood and weekend brunch.

Fusaro’s | 508.228.4100 | Family-owned and operated, homemade Italian dishes and pizza. 

Sandbar at Jetties Beach | 508.228.2279 | Oceanfront restaurant with outdoor seating. 

Miacomet Golf Course | 508.325.0333 | Lunch, dinner and Sunday brunch with outdoor seating overlooking the green.   

Lobster Trap | 508.228.4200 | Casual restaurant with classic New England seafood dishes.      nantucket food

On the Go

Lemon Press | 508.228.3800 | Healthy grab & go options, salads, wraps, smoothies and a coffee bar. 

FRESH | 508.825.2100 | Made-to-order salads, sandwiches & breakfast sandwiches. Wine, beer & spirits also available.

The Beet | 508.680.1857 | Innovative salads, lunch specials, bowls and desserts.

The Green | 508.228.1100 | Take-out breakfast and lunch with healthier options.

Boat House | 508.228.8226 | Fresh, made to order, tacos, burritos, salad bowls, burgers and more.

Glidden’s Seafood | 508.228.0912 | Fresh take-out seafood market with lunch and dinner menus. 

Something Natural | 508.228.0504 | A local favorite, hearty sandwiches, homemade breads and cookies. 

167 Raw | 508.228.2871 | Amazing, local, seafood truck with garden seating & a gourmet market. (Don’t miss the lobster roll!) 

Claudette’s Sandwich Shop | 508.257.6622 | Incredible breakfast & lunch sandwiches, coffee and pastries in ‘Sconset Village. 

Pizzeria Gemelle | 508.901.5958 | Part of the Ventuno family, serving brick oven Neapolitan pizza, salads and gelato.

Casual Dining

Island Kitchen | 508.228.2639 | A mid-island favorite, serving classic breakfast, lunch and dinner.  

Pi Pizzeria | 508.228.1130 | Neapolitan-style pizzas and delicious Italian dishes. 

Keeper’s Restaurant | 508.228.0009 | Casual comfort food on Amelia Drive with patio seating. 

Sayle’s Seafood | 508.228.4599 | Excellent, fresh seafood with an unbeatable lobster dinner. 

Millie’s | 508.228.4599 | Baja-style eats, craft cocktails and front row sunset seats in Madaket. 

Gaslight | 508.228.6464 | Japanese-Asian fusion restaurant with craft cocktails, live music and outdoor seating.

B-ACK Yard BBQ | 508.228.0227 | Sports bar with homemade BBQ plates, sides and craft beers.

The Tavern & Gazebo Bar | 508.228.1266 | Casual restaurant on the wharf open for lunch, dinner and cocktails. 

Slip 14 | 508.228.2033 | Indoor-outdoor dining offering New American dishes with water views.                          

Or, The Whale | 508.825.5897 | Bistro and bar serving lunch, dinner and weekend brunch on Main Street. 

Bar Yoshi | 508.228.1801 | Intimate restaurant with classic Japanese dishes, sushi and raw bar on Old South Wharf. 

Nantucket Tap Room | 508.228.2117 | Steak and seafood in the historical Jared Coffin House with a covered patio.

Local Farms

Moors End Farm 

40 Polpis Rd | @moorsendfarm 

Family-owned farm that includes a nursery/greenhouse that sells annuals, perennials and a produce farm with fresh vegetables and eggs. 

Pumpkin Pond Farm

25 Millbrook Rd | @pumpkinpondfarm

Nursery and organic farm with specialty plants, trees and locally grown ingredients. Pottery, gift shop and vegetables are also available on-site. 

Bartlett’s Farm 

33 Bartlett Farm Rd | @bartlettsfarm

Nantucket’s oldest family-owned farm. Known for their corn and tomatoes, they have over 100 acres of fields for growing produce and flowers. They have a garden center on-site and also set up a farm truck on Main Street in the summer. 

My Grandfather’s Farm

101 Hummock Pond Rd | @mygrandfathersfarmack

Family-owned farm along Hummock Pond Road with fresh eggs, honey, vegetables and more.  

Fog Town Farm

168 Hummock Pond Rd | @fogtownfarm

Small farm that specializes in growing salad crops, root vegetables, and much more. They also have a partner farm in North Vermont and can deliver grass-fed beef on island. 

Sustainable Nantucket

14 Federal St | @sustainablenantucket

Local non-profit working for a healthy island with local ingredients and education. Every Saturday in the summer they host a Farmer’s Market on Federal Street and have a farm stand at 168 Hummock Pond Road. 

Fine Dining

CRU | 508.228.9278 | Stylish hot spot on the water with two bars, an oyster bar and lobster rolls.

Ventuno | 508.228.4242 | Elegant Italian eatery with homemade pasta, two bars and outdoor seating.

The Nautilus | 508.228.0301 | Unique shared plates, global dishes and craft cocktails.

Lola 41 | 508.325.4001 | Chic bistro with elevated dishes, sushi bar and gourmet burgers. 

Dune | 508.228.5550 | Upscale restaurant with New American fare and craft cocktails with patio seating.

The Club Car | 508.228.1101 | California-inspired dishes attached to a retrofitted railway car with a lively bar. 

The Sea Grille | 508.325.5700 | Mid-island destination for eclectic seafood and elevated dishes.

Queequeg’s | 508.325.0992 | Cozy spot with delicious plates, dining room and patio seating. 

Oran Mor Bistro | 508.228.8655 | Charming seasonal cuisine with handcrafted cocktails, in a historic building.

The Proprietors | 508.228.7477 | Locally sourced, globally influenced dishes and fantastic cocktails.

American Seasons | 508.228.7111 | Seasonal, locally sourced dishes in a cozy, rustic setting. 

Straight Wharf | 508.228.4499 | An island favorite with beautiful dishes, bar and dining room menus and patio seating.

The Chanticleer | 508.257.4499 | Multiple dining rooms and garden views serving seasonal dishes. A favorite in ‘Sconset!

Galley Beach | 508.228.9641 | Elegant beachside restaurant with New American dishes, a beach bar and lounge area.

Via Mare | 508.228.6100 | Venetian-style dishes from the Ventuno family. Located in the Greydon House. 

Sister Ship | 508.203.6889 | A “relaxed cocktail club” with seafood-forward Mediterranean dishes and local ingredients.

Le Languedoc Bistro | 508.228.2552 | French-inspired dishes in a 1780’s tavern with indoor and outdoor seating.

Fisher Tip: We highly HIGHLY suggest making reservations in advance! Some restaurants accept same-day reservations but please check their website for the most up-to-date information. 


Written By

Fisher Real Estate