Compare Listings

PROPERTIES Under Agreement

Our market is moving quickly and the status of properties, both on and off of the market, is changing daily. Connect with a fisher agent to stay abreast of activity in real time.

Call today 508-228-4407.

Surfside- 2 Nonantum Avenue

Request Information Email To A Friend

Step into your private, picturesque Surfside paradise. Thoughtfully designed by Nantucket architects Botticelli and Pohl. Custom-built to last by renowned Cheney Brothers Building, this home showcases exceptional attention to detail across its 3,749 square feet of living space. Located just a few hundred yards from the beaches of Surfside, this secluded haven offers both convenience and exclusivity.

Inside, the home exudes warmth and character with wide oak floors, soaring ceilings, and spacious living areas flooded with natural light. Boasting 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, and a powder room, this meticulously maintained residence blends timeless architecture with contemporary comfort. 2 Nonantum Ave. is your unparalleled piece of paradise.

Surfside- 2 Nonantum Avenue placeholder

Additional Details

Upon entering, you are greeted by a spacious foyer leading to an expansive living area adorned with elegant finishes and panoramic, pastoral sunset views. The kitchen is a culinary masterpiece, featuring state-of-the-art appliances, custom cabinetry, a spacious island, and a dining room perfect for hosting intimate gatherings or large soirées. An outdoor shower is located poolside. From the side entry, you access a gracious hall leading to a large laundry room and pantry with extra refrigeration.

Retreat to the serene, spa-like primary suite, complete with a luxurious en-suite bathroom, private laundry, and a spacious walk-in closet. Outside, the lushly landscaped grounds beckon you to unwind in the idyllic outdoor oasis. Lounge by the sparkling pool, soak in the sun on the patio, or dine alfresco under the pergola while savoring the gentle ocean breeze and mesmerizing sunset vistas.

Welcome to the light-filled second-floor landing area, accessible via an elegant open-air stairway. This versatile space includes a convenient beverage refrigerator and leads to the third living area.
The primary bedroom on this level overlooks the serene backyard and pool. It boasts a soaring cathedral ceiling, an opulent bathroom with a marble and glass shower complete with a bench seat, dual sink vanities, and a private water closet, offering the ultimate in luxury and privacy.
The second bedroom, also overlooking the pool, is designed with comfort in mind and includes a bathroom with a tub/shower combination. The third suite features a pass-through office area, a bathroom with a tub/shower, and a bedroom with cathedral ceiling, generous closet space, and two built-in dressers flanking a charming window seat.

The large landing provides access to a custom ship's ladder leading to the roof walk. Enjoy the breathtaking views of the ocean, stunning sunsets and the sound of the sea. You will never want to leave.

The lower level is unfinished, spacious, high ceilings with interior and exterior access.

Property Information

  • 7
  • 4
  • 4
  • 1
  • 0.69 acres
  • 2015
  • R20
  • -
  • Well
  • Septic Tank
  • Ocean
  • Ocean, Pastoral
  • Poured
  • Oak

Take a Virtual Tour

Our exclusive listings offer dynamic 3D home tours so that you can see a property — anytime, anywhere.

Book a Showing in Person


listing property icon Property

  • Alarm
  • Central A/C
  • Insulation
  • Irrigation
  • Outdoor Shower

listing outdoor icon Outdoors

  • Deck
  • Private Pool
  • Patio
  • Porch
  • Yes
  • Yes

listing household icon Household

  • Cable
  • GFHA
  • Wolf - 6 burner with griddle
  • 2 Whirlpool


Google Map of 2 Nonantum Avenue, Nantucket, MA, USA



This family-friendly part of the island offers traditional, easy summer living with popular beaches, snack shacks, shuttle services to town and a sandy coastline ideal for kicking back and catching some sun. This neighborhood also has a three-mile bike path…

wave beach icon
tower town icon

Request More Information

Surfside- 2 Nonantum Avenue


  • 4 Beds
  • 4 + 1 half baths
  • 0.69 acres

Listing History

Surfside- 2 Nonantum Avenue

Property Type: Single-Family
Surfside- 2 Nonantum Avenue Image

Surfside- 2 Nonantum Avenue

Property Type: Single-Family
Surfside- 2 Nonantum Avenue Image

Surfside- 2 Nonantum Avenue

Property Type: Land
Surfside- 2 Nonantum Avenue Image